I remember the night I met you

Your pale blue eyes always looking like they were on the verge of tears

We spoke about nothing but somehow you felt so familiar

A cool rain was falling and we said goodbye

I remember asking you to coffee the next time we met

October leaves hanging I was playing it cool and I spilt my cup

But you just laughed and handed me your napkin

That became our spot by the window

I remember your head heavy on my shoulder

I remember the warmth of each kiss

I remember every word to your favorite songs

I remember slow dancing with you in the television light...

I don't remember what I did wrong?

But this time your pale blue eyes were really crying

We were waiting by the phone for the other to call 

I should've caved in...

I should've prayed for rain and waited for you on your front porch

I do remember the next guy that held you who wasn't me

And I do remember the next lips I kissed that weren't yours

But you will always be my sweetest surrender